By Skeeter Green
Skeeter Green Productions
S&W
Level 1

The Valley Out of Time is a series of ‘zine-sized adventures from SGP. This valley can be placed in any ongoing campaign, and is set in the “Neanderthal Period” of development. Huge monsters – both dinosaurs and otherwise – and devolved humanoids plague the area, and only the hardiest of adventurers will prevail! This series of adventures borrows heavily from classic dinosaur art, books, and movies; if you’ve ever seen a classic Frank Frazetta or Roy Krenkel painting, or read or watched The Land that Time Forgot, The Lost World, Journey to the Center of the Earth, One Million Years B.C., The Flintstones, any stop-motion film from Ray Harryhausen, etc., you’re going to feel right at home.

This twenty page digest adventure has three encounters in it. With a fuck ton of 4HD and *HD combatants. At level one. In long form paragraph form. I wish I had this chutzpah.

Twenty pages. Three encounters. You see a tribe of cavemen. A giant monitor lizard attacks the cavemen. They move camp and a giant snake attacks. Welcome to $5 worth of value, folks!

The caveman thing takes, like four pages or so. See the cavemen. And then get a run down of what they do if you approach. Or attack them. They’re a tribe of cavemen. That’s what the four pages say. And they attack you if you are hostile. There’s a staggering fucking leap of logic. There is NOTHING in those pages that any fuckwit on earth would not do if you said “tribe of cavemen.” No little vignettes. No personalities. No curious kid. Just a fucking tribe of cavemen. In four pages. 

And then a 8HD monitor lizard attacks. Then it’s followed by eight 3 HD raptors. For “Four to six characters of level 1–3 should find the encounters presented herein challenging but manageable.” Uh huh.

And, did I mention, that if you’re injured you get to make a save or get jungle rot. No spell recovery and all rolls at a -1. At level one. And if y ou wear armor you move at 25% movement speed because you are sure to fail one of the eight heat exhaustion rolls you make a day. At level one. 

The cavemen move camp after the lizard/raptor attack. On the way they get attacked by a 8HD snake. Oh, also, the cavemen are 4HD, so, good luck attacking them. 

Three encounters. Not first level. Nothing to them beyond what “cavemen” would most commonly imply. 

But, sure, it takes a lot of fucking words to get there. All laid out quite nicely in long paragraph form. Just read the entire thing. How many cavemen are at the party? Read all of the cavemen pages and then at the very bottom of it you’ll be told. Yeah you! Maybe you wanna give me $5 for this review? It has just as much value as this adventure. But, hey, it pulled in $8k in its kickstarter and has 100% 5 star reviews!

Happy fucking New Year.

This is $5 at DriveThru. There’s no preview.

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/391980/The-Valley-Out-of-Time–Welcome-to-the-Valley-SW?1892600

Bryce Lynch

View Comments

  • Aren't you tired of being sad and angry? Don't you want to review good content that will surprise you with its craft and rock solid fundamentals? NAP II is there Bryce...don't make me post like Venger begging for reviews.

  • The last Skeeter Green review got a “worst EVAR” rating and was called “an absolute piece of garbage.”

    Does this seem like an improvement?

      • After having consumed countless buckets of your free ice-cream I can state with confidence that it is a revolting mixture, lumpy, unbearably saccharine, with the texture and consistency of wood pulp. Know that I will consume any future buckets of your product with equal parts apprehension and dissapointment.

    • Have you read Bryce’s reviews of WotC products lately? And based on WotC’s recent behavior, does anyone believe that they really care about the what’s best for gamers?

  • Weird synchronicity: my home campaign is headed into a Lost World type valley and I'm been trying to get it "in gear" to do the write up, This is the second poorly written product review I've bumped into this week around that genre.

    What are the good ones?

    • Oh yeah --- I am over "'zine sized" in a big way. Melan does it well. Beyond Ultan's Door was good too, but otherwise it's like trying to squeeze a square-peg into a round hole for D&D.

Recent Posts

Fane of the Laruleans

By LixuLixuni GamingOSELevels 3-5 An Adventure module for old-school essentials, uncover the mystery of an…

1 day ago

Titan’s Throne: Infested Archives

By Mitchell DoucetteThunder Toad GamesOSELevels 1-3 The Quorth are dying. Their stone bodies erode to…

3 days ago

Filchers in the Feylight

By WIll FloraProp Co GamesOSELevel 1 A secret thieves guild, The Crimson Web, has stolen…

5 days ago

The Garden of Flesh and Bone

By Michael & Brooke StraussACKS IIThe Pheonix TomeLevel ... 5? In a remote forest far…

1 week ago

The Ruins of Arbel Monastery

By Aaron GustwillerAaron's Gaming StuffS&WLevels 1-3 [...] After the fire, the ruins gained a reputation…

1 week ago

Dungeon of the Two Kings

By R. Nelson BaileyDungeoneers Guild Games1eLevels 3-6 The dungeons of Mal-Thenga lie below the ruins…

2 weeks ago