Categories: Reviews

Lair of the Swamp King

By Brian Arnold
Muddy Paddy Games]1e
Levels 1+

A dungeon written and run in 1983, reproduced as it was left. Three levels under a swamp, ninety-three keyed areas, and a king made of something that used to be a man. Written by a teenager with graph paper, a pencil, and a stack of bestiaries and modules, and run for his friends that same year.

I’m not sure if this is a review or not. Commentary, maybe? 

This 42 page dungeon has three levels and about ninety rooms, and is an original source document from, like 1983. I might liken it to the orc caves from B2, in style of interactivity, This is an art project, presenting a historical document. I’m not sure why it exists.

So, dude found his old dungeon from 1983, typed it up, added a few notes, but otherwise published it as is. And, also, dude is making a new version of it. He new version will be 140 pages. Ouch. 

The original document is just essentially notes for the designer. Dude knew what he was talking about when he wrote the adventure out, so things are missing. This is handled by inserting some “designers notes” from 2026 in to the document that clarifies and comments on the original text. So, no cleanup, just the text from 1983 with notes added here and there for clarity.

The maps are decent, maybe a little simple in terms of level interconnectivity, based on todays standards, but in terms of same level complexity they are fine when measured by 1983 standards. The whole thing is single column, which is god awful, and uses some kind of dot-matrix front, no donut from 1983 emulating a printer, which makes me want to claw my fucking eyes out. This reminds me of those BBC and PBS historical reality tv shows where you have to live like a cornish coal miner in 1803. It’s fucking torture. Let us hope that the 2027 edition is not the same.

I likened this to the orc caves in B2. By this I mean that the adventure is mostly stabbing with a quirk or two thrown in. And, then, also, the writing style is devoted to MONSTER is doing ACTiVITY [stats], which is padded out a little via some filler words. Storage room # reads “(There are foodstuffs boxes, barrels, and a table with a scroll case on it.) Two starving fighters are grubbing out on the reserve supply of food in here. They are 1HD and have 8hp each. They wear ripped leather armor and wield long swords. One has 15sp and 4gp.”  So, MONSTER is doing ACTIVITY. And then the text is padded out a bit with “they are 1hd” and “they have 8hp each” and “they wear” and so on. It’s a very simplistic descriptive style and, no doubt, learned by B2. The MONSTER is doing ACTIVITY is a real step up from the Palace of the Vampire Queen and, at its core, contains the foundation of decent room design, trying to get to something more dynamic than static. There’s a riddle or two also, something a little more than the usual “enter a room with a monster that is shooting dice” but not much more than that. 

I don’t really understand why this was released, even as a pay what you want. It would seem to me like it’s a natural add on to a kickstarter, and I assume that’s what the 2027 140 page version will be?This is just yet another historical document, notes pulled from moms storage boxes that you clean out when she dies that show something she saved from your childhood. As an examination of home dungeon design in 1983 it could be of interest to some researcher in a hundred years, but it’s hard to see what value this provides now. 

Also, the 2027 version is supposed to have like 140 pages? For ninety or so rooms, presumably in double column format? That scares the shit out of me. 

This is Pay What You Want at DriveThru with a suggested price of $4.

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/589095/lair-of-the-swamp-king-the-original-1983-manuscript?1892600

Bryce Lynch

Share
Published by
Bryce Lynch

Recent Posts

Adventures in Zelkor’s Ferry

By Alex KammerFrog God GamesB/XLevel 1 The infamous reputation of Rappan Athuk, the Dungeon of…

2 days ago

The Hobgoblin Warlord

By Karla AdderKarla Adder PressOSRICLevels 1-3 For years, the southeast border of the Domain of…

5 days ago

The Bell of Blackthorn Hollow

FEI GamesSelf PublishedB/XLevels 3-4 Long ago a small village accepted a gift from a traveling…

1 week ago

Ataxes Must Die!

By NikolineSelf PublishedB/XLevels 1-4 Kurhan is wounded at its heart. The Akros, tower of its…

1 week ago

Treachery in the Duchy of Death

By John Keefe and Laurel NicholsonSelf PublishedOSRLevels 7-9 The Isle of Argilla has been beset…

2 weeks ago

The Ruined Watchtower

By Mountainland GamesSelf PublishedShadowdarkLevel 1 The old northern road was once safe. Now travelers are…

2 weeks ago