By Kabuki Kaiser
Self Published
OSR
Hex Crawls - Levels 1-whatever. Don’t fuck up
Danger Will Robinson! The vibe here is how I would live my life if I could. So, you know, I don’t think this is a based review but I’m aware of my love for the vibe.
Fly Me to the Moon gives you the fantastique Moon stitched into a majestic hexcrawl where each entry promises sleepless hours of adventure and d’Amberville conundrums, a moose head of a Moon in 168 hexes compatible with everything OSR from Basic to Advanced.
This 169 page hexcrawl uses about 120 pages to present about 160 hexes to explore on the moon. This is a romantic moon, with every lunar pop culture reference present. Fanciful, it remind a hex crawl, presenting situations that the party can involve themselves in. And, thusly, like most hexcrawls, you must bring to it your murderous intent to play as is. IE: hex connections/an overall thrust are weak Which isn’t a bad thing is your group like to loot The Keep in B2 cause that’s where the most XP is.
I think perhaps we need to talk about three things here. The vibe of THIS hexcrawl and then what a decent hexcrawl is in the context of if this is a decent hexcrawl. What I’m not going to do this time around is cover the evocative nature of the writing and formatting. The evocative writing is fine to good and the formatting is plain, with decent cross-references present, and at about two paragraphs to a column per, written in such a way that it is terse enough and “front loaded” enough to run pretty on the fly.
This is a romantic moon, as is romanticism, mixed in with pop culture. Every type. Cheese. Verne. About a dozen different selenites, including the Selenites, from every incarnation fo media. And, yes, this includes Apollo, the mission. Romantic as in what I’ve always wanted The Dreamlands to be.
In one hex you stumble across a hunting party. “The party consists of eight hunters led by Turambol, a petty lord clad in a star–studded pyjama, and accompanied by two court poets, both of whom ride zebras and strum luths as they travel. Turambol himself rides a white gazelle with long horns.” Fanciful, in places. If the moon has ever had a reference, in media or culture, dating back three thousand years, then it’s probably in here. And it’s going to have a fanciful bend to it. Think slim arcing towers, silver and blue light and so on.
We have incursions from other lands. An ambassador from other words, or references to Emperor Norton. Dreamy, but with consequences. “The Rotunda of Earthly Mirrors, a monumental structure of slate and alabaster tipped with a metallic silvery dome stands atop the Mons Piton’s highest peak here. The rotunda is visible from afar, its silhouette contrasting with the darkness of space.” Thematically pretty much everything matches perfectly here.
A few notes on mechanics before I move on to the nature of a hex crawl. The map is nothing, really. Imagine a black page with hex numbers in it. There’s your terrain. There’s a light background image on the map but it’s artistic. What “travel type” we should consider the moon is not noted, although there are some low gravity notes. Whatever “These basaltic plains lie buried
beneath silt, ash, and black sand” is/are. Except in some places we have wildflower meadows, cultivated fields, groves of fungi and a land of chasms and canyons and the Marsh of Rot. No clue man, we’re just handwaving that. These are ten mile hexes, but mostly flat, I think? There is a landmark or two on the map, but, really, a better job at landmarks on the map would have been nice, as well as horizon stuff, to get players moving from hex to another with “in the distance you see” type of things. A better version of the map would solve most of my bitching here, maybe with a couple of travel/vision notes on it.
And then, the nature of a hex crawl. What is its purpose? Dread has you wandering around, looking, essentially, for lairs, which contain loot, so you can level. Wilderlands, being a more platonic example of a classical hexcrawl, contains loot hexes as well as things for the party to exploit, or to get in to trouble with. More of a situational encounters, in that there is a situation to interact with … while you still look for personal gain to exploit. This is going to fall solidly in to the situational category, as you will meet a wide variety of people and encounter a large number of areas to find some gain in, either through looting or through making friends. There are lots of ogres wearing bejeweled crowns to talk to, to reference a favorite situation of mine in other adventures. Stab the potentially friendly dude to get the XP? Make friends?
And this gets to the reference to The Keep in B2 earlier. Are you willing to murder hobo this place up? That would be a more traditional Wilderlands way to explore. Taking each hex individually and exploiting it. You’re going to need a party in the right mindset. And this succeeds admirably in that. You can rescue people/creatures and do some tasks for others if you are so inclined, and you can put the place to the sword and gather the loot also.
What is lacking here is an overall plot. And I’m using that word very VERY loosely. Interconnections between the hexes. There are a few of those, but they feel intentional and constructed in a blunt way.
I want to take this hex as an example: “t’s that time of the year again! Once more, the Flying Broom Acrobatics Competition has gathered next to an antique blue marble amphitheatre rising from the cloudy Mare” The Selenians here are excited about this. But no other Selenian encountered will mention it. There is no overview of a larger situations/situations going on that a DM can sprinkle in here and there to make the place seem more like the realm of intelligent beings that it is. There’s a loose “my enemy is the aphid-lord, please help me kill them” but no larger … geopolitical context? Not in politics, perse, but in terms of larger situations to embroil yourself in. And no summary, anywhere, to help a DM toss some things in. A page of this would have really helped, and perhaps a little more work on the hexes to help connect them just a bit more. Again, some of this DOES exist, but it feels isolated. So, read a 120 pages and take some notes.
As noted, I like this vibe/theming a lot. It’s consistent. And it provides interactivity for a party willing to mix things up. As a view of the moon, in terms of theming and encounters, I would be hard pressed to believe someone could do better. The map/mechanics are a let down, and it would be a much stronger product with a little summary of situations to help the DM interconnect things more and/or a few larger situations embedded i a stronger way.
Experienced murder hobos are gonna have a field day.
This is $8 at DriveThru. The preview is listed as fourteen pages and although a few are blank pages you do indeed to get see several hexes and get a sense of the style of encounters you are to encounter, both in romanticism and in hex-crawl nature, so, good preview.
https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/540802/fly-me-to-the-moon?1892600
A question came to mind during this. How do you handle “hidden depth” of resources? This happened in several places in this, and in other adventures as well. A platonic example here may be some mushroom that, if you kill, you could make their large caps in to umbrellalike things that act as feather falling. How do you telegraph this to the party? I mean when you encounter a note like “The spleens can be used to make an amulet of proof against poison.” Great! How do we know that? A simple DM note to the party, maybe during combat, that they seem to fall slower than they should?
By The Danger ForgeSelf PublishedOSELevels 6-8 Tales of Atan-Thu are told to frighten both the…
By Dougal CochraneSelf PublishedDOlmenwoodLevels ... 2-3? No Funkadelics appear in this adventure. [...] Lately, the…
By Brad KerrNecrotic GnomeOSELevels 5-7 A cruel warlord hoards horses and power at the edge…
By Pedro GilLa Marco del EsteOSRLevels 4-6 Beyond the Pirate Islands, in the southern seas,…
By Marco FischerSavvy Thief StudiosOSR"Low Levels" [No Marketing Blurb] This fourteen page adventure uses four…
By Stephen J. JonesUnsound MethodsOSELevels 4-6 Twenty years ago the denizens of Faerie poured forth…
View Comments
From reading the review I didn't really get ' the best' vibes. It is not often that a review from Prince shows more enthusiasm about the material.
Going by Bryce's usual fare, this absolutely deserves to be in 'The Best' category.
Map was a legitimate criticism. Lack of random encounters should have been another one. Reward is wonky (even if you figure out to use Silver = gold for XP) and no level range. I don't mind the lack of a strong/explicit overarching design or lynchpin, it really is just a place to gallumph around in with some threads that are there if you want to find them, but its worth bringing up explicitly in the review (whereas I think mine implies).
Its mostly good encounters, with some links, scattered across a 14 x 14 map. Very much worth it.
Mechanical gripes aside, I miss the Patrick-Stuart-y era of the OSR when everyone was constantly trying to creatively one-up each other, and set their adventures in imaginatively strange locations, rather than the hyper-functional 'stab 10 goblins in a room' slop that dominates the scene now. The whole 'hexcrawl but on the Romantic moon!!!' conceit makes me nostalgic for those times. Will be checking this out for sure
Creativity is all well and good, but I personally hate wacky cornball shit like this.
The moon as an exotic alien environment to explore? Cool.
The moon being made of cheese and magically turning your eyes into big pizza pies? Corny.
Just my opinion, no intent to yuck someone's yum.
Yeah. Never been less enthused about a "best". I can _almost_ handle Bryce's tendency to whimsy when it tends fairytale because I know how to lean with that...
But I couldn't handle the clowns in ASE2 and this one seems a little too gonzo for me. I'm sure plenty would enjoy it on a beer and pretzels one shot night or something though when the groans are part of the fun.
Agree that hand-wavey, gonzo, slapdash stuff doesn't really work at the table for me, because I like a level of buy-in from my players. My comment was assuming this module has some level of internal consistency which makes the whimsy believable. I'll have to read it to find out.
The 'classic' OSR stuff I'm thinking of (Patrick Stuart's Deep Carbon Observatory, Through Ultan's Door, Gus L's stuff, etc) combines the imagination with a competent sense of world-building
Hey, Kabuki here. First off, thank you, Bryce! Love reading those reviews. Plus 'Best' woo oo.
Then, hell no, it's not Gonzo like "there's no reason/inner logic/consistency for this, fuck you that's why", it's Outer Planar unusual, with very much of an inner logic of its own. Spent hours making sense of things so your players could too. Let's not assume Gonzoism because cheese here.
Hey, wondering where one might find the “luxury, matte print hardcover” for purchase? Thanks!
It's on Lulu! Drivethrurpg doesn't do hardcover for this format.
Waves of creativity followed by waves of consolidation and simplification. That's all she wrote. I do think there are some clear positives (Productive Gabor & associates era, Hawk, Trent published, I'm getting stuff out, Fight On# back, plentiful good and useful vanilla adventures seeing print etc.) but this era of consolidation too must end.